One year on, consumers face a patchwork of protections, with BNPL remaining unregulated in some markets.

Slow transposition is not the only concern. In some countries, national rules go beyond the proportionate framework set out in Brussels. Each addition may be well-intentioned, but together they cut against CCD2’s aim of modernizing credit. Belgium offers a telling example: its rules require Belgian consumers to give signed confirmation of delivery before a credit agreement takes effect. This obligation was designed in the 1990s, when e-commerce was just starting, and is impractical in today’s e-commerce world, in which consumers want payment and credit products embedded in their online shopping experience. In the Netherlands, where national implementation is still being discussed, credit providers may be required to create a dedicated register of merchants to be held by the financial regulator. Yet it is not clear how this register would concretely benefit consumers. Taken together, these market-by-market differences mean a provider serving consumers across the EU must build and maintain several versions of the same product, which runs against the spirit of the single market.

We are not suggesting CCD2 needs to be revised, nor are we seeking a delay to implementation. We are ready for CCD2 and believe it will bring great improvements to the market for consumers and providers. But late transposition and unnecessary gold-plating result in poor outcomes. To return to the Belgian example, the final rules containing the outdated delivery-signature requirement were only published in July 2026. This has meant providers have had only a few weeks, rather than the 12 months intended by the directive, to get everything in place to be compliant by November 2026. Such a short transition period affects the whole ecosystem, not just credit providers. Retailers that advertise or offer BNPL credit at checkout must adapt too, just as the busiest shopping season of the year begins.

The goal is not to remove national protections but to apply one high standard everywhere. A consumer should not receive weaker protection because their government was late, or different protection because of a national quirk.

CCD2 is also a useful cautionary tale for Europe’s competitiveness agenda. A directive sets an objective and leaves each country to write its own rules, which, exactly as we have seen with CCD2, can lead to delay, divergence and gold-plating. A regulation applies directly, everywhere, at the same time. Moving more of Brussels’ rulemaking to regulations would, as a former Italian prime minister, Enrico Letta, argues in his report on the future of the single market, do wonders for the overall cohesiveness of the EU. Another former Italian prime minister, Mario Draghi, agrees, and recommended in his report on European competitiveness that directives be phased out in favor of more regulations. For its part, the European Commission appears, at the very least, to recognize the problem, and in its recent communication on the competitiveness of the banking sector committed to look more closely at national implementation of CCD2 and other directives. We welcome that scrutiny.

The goal is not to remove national protections but to apply one high standard everywhere. A consumer should not receive weaker protection because their government was late, or different protection because of a national quirk. Fragmentation does not protect consumers. It leaves gaps and makes products harder to compare.

So what should happen now? The immediate priority is to close the open infringement cases, which should encourage member states to finish transposition.

More broadly, EU co-legislators should learn from this rollout for the next round of consumer law. As debates begin on the Digital Fairness Act, policymakers have an opportunity to choose a regulation from the start, rather than repeating the patchwork of CCD2.

Share.
Exit mobile version